• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Don Monaco Pizzeria & Catering: Savory Comfort Food in Oak Forest

Don Monaco Pizzeria & Catering, located in Oak Forest, Illinois, is a charming eatery known for its family recipes and engaging atmosphere. This pizzeria offers a variety of dishes, including crispy, buttery crust pizzas and flavorful sides like jalapeño poppers and southwest salads. Although some reviews express concerns about the freshness of their pizza slices, many local patrons appreciate the balanced flavors and affordable prices. The cozy, mom-and-pop vibe enhances the experience, making it a worthwhile stop for pizza lovers seeking comfort food in a welcoming environment. Overall, Don Monaco is a hidden gem with potential for greater community support.

Photos & Gallery

Don Monaco Pizzeria & Catering: Reviews & Ratings

Billi Jo Lear Thrasher
Billi Jo Lear Thrasher

Our pizza was WAY over cooked. Being on vacation, it's not easy sometimes to just hop back to a place to say something. We were early to get them so I'm unsure why.

David Alvarez
David Alvarez

They cook their pizza slices a day before..freeze them..reheat them up to serve you, the consumer. The guy on the phone told me that it was still considered fresh…red flag. They should consider making a fresh slice of pizza the same day. When I did get my slice of pizza it was noticeable that they made it like a day before. Not really what I expect to get from a pizza joint. I’d rather get a frozen pizza in a store then. I’m not sure how they make their full pizzas to order. I just know the slices are not fresh to order.

Connor Devine
Connor Devine

Pizza, jalepeno poppers, nachos, and tomato bread are my go to’s. Made by a family who have their recipes down. Such a cheap price but don’t skimp on flavor. Should have considerably more business from the local community (I’m an oak forester)

Tommy Mac
Tommy Mac

Smells just like a typical mom and pop pizza place which is amazing. Place is a little tough to spot from the street, so keep your eyes peeled. Pizza overall is very good. The crust is crispy and buttery and the cheese is a big tangy. Reminds me a lot of Home Run Inn (actual restaurant, not the frozen stuff you buy at the store). Worth the price for sure. Staff is engaging and efficient.

CeeDee Zee
CeeDee Zee

We always order from here and it’s great! We always get pizza and wings ! Today… I also got the southwest salad and OMGEE!! it is amazing! I already ate some I’m full and still have more than half left (lunch tomorrow!)

Samuel Barsi
Samuel Barsi

Accidentally ordered a stuffed pizza instead of a regular thin crust. Felt bad because it was in their final hour of being open! That's what I get for taking a gummy and trying to order pizza. Sorry to the owner for ordering a deep dish this late, but I have to say it was a really good pizza and my wife and I enjoyed it despite my mistake ordering. I ordered it medium-well done and it had a good cook on it/was cooked to order. Need to go back and order the thin crust. Where is Dave Portnoy for this place?

Melba Lee
Melba Lee

If your looking for an affordable pizza lunch on the go this is a good spot. Huge pizza slice and can of pop for $6! We cut one of the slices into 3 slices just because it’s easier to eat. Tonz of cheese and sausage. Will definitely go again for this special . It is just a grab n go no dine in.

Connor Devine
Connor Devine

Amazing family owned restaurant. They have prices that make me feel good eating out. For as much as getting McDonalds for a family of 5 you can get a 3 course meal that satisfies an entire family

Location

Located in the heart of Oak Forest, Illinois, Don Monaco Pizzeria & Catering stands out as a delightful spot for pizza lovers. This charming establishment, nestled at 14721 Central Ave, offers a cozy, mom-and-pop vibe that echoes the warmth of homemade cooking. With a phone number of +1 708-535-1212, they strive to serve the community with flavors that are both comforting and satisfying.

Upon entering, patrons are immediately enveloped in the inviting aroma of freshly baked goods—a hallmark of traditional pizzerias. The menu features an array of classic favorites, including crispy pizzas, savory jalapeño poppers, and tempting nachos, all made with cherished family recipes. Reviewer Connor Devine highlights the excellent price-to-flavor ratio, noting that the food is crafted with care, ensuring it offers both substance and taste.

However, not all voices have echoed their approval. Customers like Billi Jo Lear Thrasher and David Alvarez have raised concerns regarding the freshness of certain items, particularly pizza slices that are reportedly prepared in advance. While some may find this a drawback, it’s essential to understand that every establishment has its growing pains as it navigates the fine balance between efficiency and quality.

Amidst the variations in customer experiences, there are shining testimonials about the engaging staff and the overall atmosphere, as highlighted by Tommy Mac. He praises the pizza's crispy, buttery crust and tangy cheese, drawing comparisons to renowned local establishments. This speaks volumes about the dedication of the team behind Don Monaco, who work tirelessly to create dishes that evoke a sense of nostalgia and community spirit.

For those seeking variety, the menu doesn’t disappoint. CeeDee Zee's rave review of the southwest salad exemplifies the surprises that await beyond just pizza. It’s evident that Don Monaco aims to cater to a diverse clientele, blending traditional Italian flavors with innovative culinary creations.

Whether you're a lifelong Oak Forester or just passing through, Don Monaco Pizzeria & Catering invites you to indulge in their rich flavors and heartfelt service. While there may be room for improvement, the charm of this pizzeria lies in its quest to find that perfect balance, making it a spot worth exploring. So, grab a slice or two, engage with the staff, and enjoy a taste of local flavor that promises to leave a lasting impression.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards